Notes New role
Joining Luxury Presence
I've joined Luxury Presence as Director of Product Design. Real estate is in a fight over who owns the listing and the client, and I want to build for the agents caught in the middle of it.
I’ve joined Luxury Presence as Director of Product Design. I’m leading the design team that builds AI products for real estate agents.
The company is new to me. The industry isn’t. At Digs we helped first-time buyers save for a home. At Movoto I worked on a search portal, so I’ve sat on that side of the table. At Flow I designed for residents and for the teams who run their buildings.
This time the person I’m designing for is the agent, and it’s an interesting moment to be on their side.
An industry that began with sharing notes
In the late 1800s, as the National Association of Realtors tells it, brokers got into the habit of meeting at their local association’s office to trade notes on the homes each of them had for sale. They agreed to pay one another for help finding a buyer. That arrangement became the multiple listing service, and the American housing market still runs on it.
The deal in that room was simple. I’ll show you my listings if you show me yours, and we’ll both sell more homes. Competitors agreed to cooperate, and for more than a century that agreement held.
Most of what is happening in real estate right now is an argument about whether it still does.
Then the listings went online
For a long time the MLS was a book, and then a database, that only agents could open. If you wanted to know what was for sale, you called one.
The search portals changed that. Zillow launched in 2006, and within a few years anyone could browse every home on the market from the couch. Today most buyers start their search on a portal, long before they talk to an agent.
It’s worth being clear about how that business works. The homes on a portal are agents’ listings. The listings bring the audience, and the portal then sells agents a way to reach that audience, as advertising or as a share of the commission when a lead closes. An agent can end up paying to be introduced to a buyer who is looking at the agent’s own listing.
Agents go along with it for a good reason. That is where the buyers are. No single agent can match that audience, so most of them treat the portals as a cost of doing business.
Zillow and Compass
Over the last two years that arrangement has turned into an open fight.
Compass, the largest brokerage in the country, has built part of its strategy on marketing homes privately before they go on the MLS. Its argument is that a seller should decide how their home is marketed, and that some sellers want to test a price before the whole market is watching.
Zillow’s argument is that a listing shown to some buyers should be shown to all of them. In 2025 it set a rule: if a home is marketed publicly and isn’t shared with the MLS within a day, Zillow won’t show it at all.
Compass sued, calling the rule anticompetitive. In February of this year a federal judge declined to block it. In March, Zillow revised the rule and Compass dropped the case. By then Compass had also bought Anywhere, the company behind Coldwell Banker and Century 21, and become much larger. In May, Zillow filed a suit of its own against Compass and the Chicago-area MLS.
I’m not going to pick a side here. Both companies have a real argument, and both are also protecting their business. What interests me is what they’re fighting over. It’s the same thing those brokers were trading in the 1800s: who gets to see the listing, and who the client belongs to.
Why agents don’t want to be beholden to a platform
Look at this from the seat of a single agent.
Their listings are the inventory on a portal they don’t control. The rules for how they can market a home are being set by companies far bigger than they are, and argued over in courts they’ll never appear in. Any of those rules can change in a quarter. The 2024 commission settlement made things harder still: buyers now sign an agreement before they tour a home, and agents have to explain what they’re worth, in writing, to people who may have found them through an ad.
An audience you rent can be repriced or taken away. Agents know this. The best ones I’ve met talk about it the way any business owner talks about depending on one big customer.
So the question an agent keeps coming back to is a simple one. Which parts of my business are mine?
Owning your own platform
This is the reason I took the job.
Luxury Presence builds the websites, marketing and AI tools that agents use to grow their businesses. The idea underneath it is that an agent’s business should sit on ground they own. Their site carries their name and their brand. The people who find them there become their contacts and their clients. If the portals change the rules again next year, that part of the business doesn’t move.
An agent on their own platform can still use the portals, and most will. The difference is that they’re choosing to, and they have somewhere else to stand.
I think that’s also the healthiest outcome for the industry. Portals are a good way to search for a home. Big brokerages give agents real support. Neither one should be the only door a client can walk through to reach an agent.
Where AI comes in
Owning your platform has always been possible. It was also a lot of work.
An agent is a small business, and usually a very small one. Building a brand, keeping a website current, showing up in search, answering leads at all hours and staying in touch with every past client is what a marketing team does. Most agents don’t have one. That’s a big part of why renting an audience from a portal has been the easier choice.
AI changes that math. Software can now write a first draft, follow up with a lead, keep track of who needs a call, and take a task from start to finish while the agent is at a closing. A solo agent can run the kind of marketing that used to need a team.
Yes, that means I design agents for agents. I’ve made my peace with the sentence.
The design problem
The hard questions here are design questions, which is what makes the work exciting to me.
An agent’s name is on everything their software does. If an AI sends a message to a client, it has to sound like the agent and be right about the facts. So trust comes first: what the product does on its own, what it asks about, and how an agent can see what happened while they were busy.
Much of this work also has no screen. I’ve written before about products where the screen is optional and about treating an agent as a job description. Agents live on their phones and in their cars, and they have very little patience for software that wants their attention.
And there’s taste. If the point is that an agent owns their brand, then everything we make for them has to be something they’d be proud to put their name on.
What I’m here to do
The brokers in that room in the 1800s built something that lasted because each of them kept their own business and their own clients while they shared. I’d like agents to come out of this period the same way: independent, well equipped, and not dependent on any one company, including ours, for their living.
I’ll write more here as we go. If you’re an agent, or you design for them, I’d like to hear from you.
Sources
- National Association of Realtors, Multiple Listing Service (MLS): What Is It, for the history of the MLS.
- National Association of Realtors, NAR Settlement FAQs, for the 2024 changes to buyer agreements.
- RISMedia, Zillow Bans Private Listings, Setting Up Showdown, April 2025.
- RISMedia, Judge Denies Compass’s Bid to Block Zillow Rules, February 2026.
- Inman, Compass Drops Antitrust Lawsuit Against Zillow, March 2026.
- HousingWire, Compass closes $1.6B Anywhere merger, January 2026.
- The Real Deal, Zillow sues Chicago MLS and Compass over private listings, May 2026.
- Zillow, Zillow sues MRED and Compass, May 2026, for Zillow’s own account.
More notes
-
Building a playground for AI-native learning
Bixel is where I build bots and agents, test data extraction and compare models. Here is what is in it, what broke, and what it taught me.
-
Getting a bot verified by Cloudflare
What Cloudflare's Verified Bots program is, what it took for a one-person crawler to get in, and what it says about bot and human traffic on the web.
-
Headless products make research the design work
If customers reach your product through an agent instead of your interface, the design that matters is how well you understand what they were trying to do.